Wrong Man Jailed 2 Weeks on 1978 Murder Charge Says Ordeal 'Horrific'

A New Lenox man held in the county jail for two weeks on a 35-year-old murder charge was set free.

A New Lenox widower held 13 days on a murder warrant for a different man said he feared he would be locked up for the rest of his life.

"I panicked," said Pedro Hernandez, a 67-year-old father of four who was arrested March 14 in connection with a 1978 murder.

"I know for this crime they can send you away for life," he said.

Hernandez was taken into custody by the New Lenox police following a traffic accident. He was charged with driving under the influence, and when officers ran his name and identifiers, they reportedly discovered someone matching his description was wanted for a 35-year-old Joliet murder.

The wanted man, also named Pedro Hernandez, is 66-years-old, according to court records. This Pedro Hernandez allegedly stabbed a man named Julian Briseno in the chest on April 2, 1978, killing him.

Joliet Police Chief Mike Trafton said he will release details of the murder but those details have yet to be made available.

The Pedro Hernandez arrested March 14 was taken into custody on a no-bond arrest warrant and locked up in the county jail. He appeared in court the following day and was scheduled to return to court April 5.

He said he begged court personnel not to make him wait in jail that long.

"I said, 'Ma'am, please don't wait until April 5," he recalled.

Hernandez said he joined the military at 17 and knows "sometimes you live hard," but that nothing prepared him for the misery of the Will County jail—or the terrible food served there.

"It was horrific," he said. "No human being should be treated like they do."

Hernandez, who says he has lived in New Lenox for the last 25 years, still does not know what took so long for the authorities to figure out he was not the Pedro Hernandez they were looking for, or why they did not simply check his fingerprints against those of the man wanted for murder.

"That's what I kept telling them," he said.

Charles B. Pelkie, the spokesman for the Will County State's Attorneys Office, said prosecutors and police teamed to determine whether the right man was in custody.

"We've got a murder case from a different administration that was filed 35 years ago," Pelkie said. "We worked closely with the Joliet Police Department to determine whether this person was the subject of the warrant and worked quickly to release the person once we realized he was not the subject of the warrant.

"They were combing through evidence and police reports that dated back 35 years," Pelkie said of the police, adding that detectives were trying to locate and speak with witnesses from the 1978 killing.

As it turned out, Hernandez did not have to wait until his April 5 court date. prosecutors filed papers Thursday afternoon acknowledging he is "not the defendant int the above captioned matter" and ordering his release from jail.

Now that he's out and can look back at his arrest and time in jail, Hernandez said he will "live with it," but also noted that, "Right now, I'm looking for a lawyer."

Check out all the area court news on our Facebook page.

You can't handle the truth! April 07, 2013 at 07:26 PM
Well said Dave!
Resurrected April 07, 2013 at 11:31 PM
Dave H you still don't grasp it, the Police acted properly and within their bounds!
Dave H April 08, 2013 at 02:29 PM
Based on what we see in this article it is probably true that suspicion of this guy was in order. The guy looked similar, he had the same name. That passes the smell test. What doesn't pass the smell test is that the by police had to ask a judge to hold this guy. This guy was held far beyond what is a reasonable amount of time. I hope that never happens to anyone ever again. Everyone in this process may have been 100% legally correct upon investigation. If this happened to me I would be suing anyone and everyone connected to this detainment. Legal doesn't mean moral or right.
William Taylor April 11, 2013 at 04:13 PM
Dave thanks for having COMMON SENSE.
You can't handle the truth! April 14, 2013 at 06:57 PM
Bottom line this man should've never been arrested for murder and held on a murder charge. He was arrested because his name is Pedro Hernandez, the date of birth didn't even match. Sorry but you can't just go around arresting people because they have the same name as a person who murdered someone. It appears to me like State and the police took their sweet time with their investigation and letting this guy go! Shame on the New Lenox cop who arrested him, the State and JPD for their lackadaisical slow poke investigation. I'd sue too! That is why these agencies have insurance!!!


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »